Have you ever wondered what is the best cut of beef for roast beef? I’m sure we’ve all heard different people tell us there is one cut of beef better than all the others for this, but few have taken the time to investigate whether this is true, and no-one has published their findings. To save you time, I’ve done the work for you and then written an article about it!
All About Beef Roasts, From Chuck to Rump
For many, the holidays aren’t complete without a hunk of meat on the table. Ham it up, lamb it up, pull out the porchetta or, for maximum impact, get the big beef roast.
There’s something so 90s supermodel-iconic about a standing rib roast: gorgeous, a little (okay, a lot) intimidating, worth a lot of dough.
But there are other less attention-getting roasts, the waifs if you will, that can just as handily steal the spotlight. The strip loin, for example, is the Epicurious team’s pick as the roast with the most for your Christmas fete.
Not familiar with it? That’s understandable. Aliases run amok at the meat counter—the strip loin roast is sometimes called the top loin roast, not to be confused with the top sirloin roast, which is also known as top butt—which makes the buying process that much more confusing.
You just need to know what to ask. I called Dave Gathy, master butcher and part owner of Conscious Carnivore, a whole-animal butcher shop in Madison, Wis., to break it down.
A little anatomy
Roasts are cut from the steer’s chuck, or shoulder; the rib and loin areas; the round, or butt and back leg, and the brisket, or chest.
Generally, fattier roasts come from the animal’s forequarter, or front end, Gathy said.
Or think of it this way: The most tender—and expensive—roasts come from the parts that move the least (think rib roast and tenderloin). Conversely, the tougher roasts that take best to braising come from the areas that get the most exercise, like the round. These might be considered less special-occasion but, said Gathy, “they’re delicious and much more affordable.”
Where and when to buy
Supermarkets carry all the common cuts, but for the most variety, find a butcher shop. Not all are like Conscious Carnivore, which sources its meat from the owner’s farm, but any good butcher shop will cut meat to order. You can specify how big a roast to want, and you might discover other cuts you weren’t aware of.
It’s a good idea to order your roast in advance and bring it home no more than three to four days ahead of when you plan on cooking it.
Keep the meat refrigerated in its original wrapping, set inside a large pan that’ll catch any seepage. As Gathy points out, “The bigger the roast, the more blood is going to come out of it as it sits in the fridge.” You’ll be thankful when it’s time to unwrap it.
Mustard-Seed-Crusted Prime Rib Roast with Roasted Balsamic Onions Marcus Nilsson
Here’s a rundown of roasts and some of their aliases, going from a steer’s front to back.
Chuck roast. Also: pot roast, chuck roll. A budget cut from the shoulder, it has marbling throughout, making it ideal for one-pot cooking.
Clod roast. Also: arm roast, pot roast. The clod or arm is leaner and a little less expensive than chuck. It is best braised.
Brisket. A Jewish holiday favorite from the breast area, it consists of the lean flat cut and the fatty point or deckle. It’s usually the flat cut you’re getting when you order brisket, but you can specify the point or the entire “packer’s cut” brisket.
Rib roast. Also: standing rib roast, prime rib. Seven ribs make up a rib roast, the “creme de la creme,” Gathy said. “It’s got the fat, it’s got the marbling.” What’s called the large end of the rib roast (even though physically the ribs are smaller), closer to the chuck, is fattier; it gets leaner as you move toward the “small” (but actually larger) back end, which connects to the strip loin. One rib for every two people is plenty, so let your butcher know how many guests you’re feeding and which end of the rib roast you prefer.
Strip loin roast. Also: top loin roast. A leaner roast from the same muscle as the rib roast, toward the animal’s butt. This is where boneless New York strip steaks and bone-in Kansas City strip steaks are cut from; left whole, “it’s the next best thing to a standing rib roast,” Gathy said.
Tenderloin. The most tender roast of all—it’s under the spine— with almost no fat or flavor. It’s tapered in shape, the middle being the “center cut.” The labor involved and waste produced in trimming and tying a tenderloin drives up the price.
Top sirloin roast. Also: top butt. Cut from the hip bone, it’s lean but flavorful with some marbling. It’s not a super-cheap cut but still more affordable than the tenderloin. Gathy likes its versatility, cut into steaks or cooked in stew or stir-fry.
Tri-tip roast. This small triangular roast is taken from the top of the sirloin and has “perfect marbling,” said Gathy. It’s one of his favorites, especially for smoking or grilling.
Top round roast. Also: inside round. A humble cut from the inside of the animal’s back leg, similar to the top sirloin in fat and flavor. This is what’s typically used for deli roast beef.
Bottom round roast. Also: rolled rump roast. Another budget cut from the outside of the back leg. “It’s my favorite roast off the rump because it has really nice marbling, more than the top round,” Gathy said.
Eye of round roast. A circular, very lean roast from the bottom round. Like the other rump roasts, it’s best when roasted and thinly sliced; often used in pho and ramen.
Sirloin tip roast. Also: knuckle. A budget cut taken right off the knee. It’s similar to the top sirloin roast, lean but flavorful.
What Cut Of Meat Is Roast Beef?
What Are the Best Beef Cuts for Roast Beef? In terms of fat and flavor, top round roast (also known as inside round roast) and top sirloin roast (also known as top sirloin roast) are the most prevalent cuts of beef used for roast beef. Top Sirloin Roast (also known as Top Butt) – this cut of meat is lean and full of taste, with just a hint of marbling on the surface.
In the oven, roast the meat until it is 24 grams of protein and 180 calories. In the indirect grill, grill the meat until it is not pink.
What is the best cut of meat for roast beef?
The best cuts of meat to use for roast beef are as follows: 1 ribeye roast (or equivalent). Tenderloin Roast (serves 2). 3 pound Prime Rib Roast Petite Tender on the Shoulders. 5 Sirloin Tip Center Steak (Sirloin Tip) 6 ounces of bottom round steak 7 Roasted Round Eye of Round. Roasted Sirloin Tip for 8 people. Chuck Roast (nine pound). 10 Roasted Rump of Beef
What is roast beef?
Roast beef is a subject that many of us have varying levels of understanding about. For some of us, it may be a hearty pot roast with plenty of vegetables. Another favorite food for some people is deli slices from their neighborhood sandwich shop. Roast beef may be made from any cut of beef as long as it is cooked in a roasting pan, which is what roast beef is.
What is the most tender part of the beef roast?
The prime rib, with its enormous, curving rib bones, is the most aesthetically stunning of the ribs. It’s the most soft and flavorful of all the beef roasts, and it’s the most highly marbled. On the basis of taste and softness, the strip loin, which is the cut used for New York strip steaks, is the most comparable cut.
Which cut makes the best roast beef?
The Chateaubriand beef tenderloin roast is often regarded as the most tender cut of beef available for roasting purposes. This cut of beef is derived from the loin portion of the cow, which is located just below the backbone, behind the rib section, and in front of the sirloin section of the animal.
What is the name of a roast beef?
|Round||Bottom Round Roast Eye Round Roast Pikes Peak Roast (Aka Heel of Round) Round Tip Roast Rump Roast Tip Roast Silverside (name used outside of U.S.)||=|
|Shank & Brisket||Brisket Whole Brisket Flat Cut||=|
What are the best cuts of beef in order?
What is the best cut of beef to order? The Ultimate Top 10 List of Everything
- 1 flank flank. The flank steak is one of the most widely consumed cuts of beef in the world.
- The New York Strip is number two. The New York strip steak is a cut from the short loin.
- Among the cuts of meat available are: 3 skirt
- 4 ribeye
- 5 prime rib
- 6 Tenderloin
- 7 Sirloin
- 8 porterhouse.
How can I tell what cut of beef I have?
The number one flannelled. The flank steak is one of the most popular cuts of beef in the United States.
2nd Avenue in New York. The New York strip steak is derived from a piece of the short loin.
Tenderloin. 7 Sirloin. 8 Porterhouse. 3 Skirt. 4 Ribeye. 5 Prime Rib. 6 Tenderloin
What’s the cheapest cut of beef?
- 11 low-cost beef slices for dinner preparation on a tight budget steak from the top round (aka london broil) The London Broil is a thick cut that may be used in a variety of ways.
- Prime rib of beef
- Sirloin tip steak
- Eye of round steak
- Bottom round steak
- Bottom round roast
- Arm chuck roast
- Top blade steak
- Top round roast
- Prime rib of beef
Is Chuck steak and chuck roast the same?
It is sliced in a cylindrical or oblong form, with the grain running in the same direction as the long side of the flesh. Chuck roast is a tough cut of meat that frequently contains a portion of the blade bone; it is served in a crockpot or on the grill. Chuck steak is the same type of meat as chuck roast, but it is sliced into slices that are one to three inches thick.
What is the most tender cut of beef?
A filet mignon is a beef tenderloin cut that is considered to be the most tender of all. It is cut from the middle of the tenderloin. Even though it’s lean, it has a buttery succulence that makes it melt in your mouth. Grilling, pan-searing, and broiling in the oven are all possibilities. A filet, which is available in a variety of weights, is ideal for one person.
What are the eight grades of beef?
Understand your quality grade There are eight overall quality grades: Prime, Choice, Select, Standard, Commercial, Utility, Cutter, and Canner. Prime is the highest quality grade, followed by Choice and Select. Since 1927, they have been in use by the cattle industry as a feed additive.
Which is better sirloin or ribeye?
What is the best type of steak to use for grilling? Because ribeye steaks have a larger fat content than sirloin steaks, they don’t cook as well on the grill as sirloin steaks. It’s the perfect choice for a wonderful, old-fashioned smokey taste or for some barbecue cooking because it’s generally a thinner cut that can be cooked more quickly without being overcooked or dry.
What are the 9 cuts of beef?
- The Primal Meat Cuts: The 9 Best Choices Chuck. Chuck comes from the cow’s front top region, which sees a lot of movement. Rib comes from the cow’s lower section. Next, we’ll talk about ribs, short loin, sirloin, round, brisket, fore shank, short plate, and other cuts of meat that we love.
What part of cow is roast?
Cooking a roast beef refers to the method of preparation rather than the specific piece of meat. Roast beef may be sourced from any section of the cow; however, roast beef is most commonly sourced from the sirloin, ribs, rump, and rear legs regions of the cow since the flesh is more soft and suited for roasting in these areas.
What are the secondary cuts of beef?
- Roast beef is a cooking method rather than a specific piece of beef. It is sometimes referred to as roasted meat. Roast beef may be sourced from any section of the cow
- however, roast beef is most commonly sourced from the sirloin, ribs, rump, and rear legs regions of the cow since the flesh is more soft and suited for roasting in these locations.
Which roast is a better cut of meat?
- Shoulder Petite Tender
- Sirloin Tip Center Steak
- Sirloin Tip Bottom Round Steak
- Eye of Round roast
- Chuck roast
- Beef Rump Roast
- Prime Rib roast
What is the worst cut of meat?
Because of this, the various portions of round fall firmly on the opposite end of the spectrum, to the point that The Splendid Table has referred to eye of round as ″one of the few unredeemable pieces of meat.″ Aside from being rough and lacking in flavor, round steak is the poorest cut of meat available, according to most experts.
What is the best cut of beef for roasting?
″Christmas nights are my tapas night, with a leg of acorn-fed Jamon Salamanca or Guijuelo, salami, and chorizos, as well as a variety of tapas, as the centerpiece.″ In addition to our Calderetta de Cabrito (goat stew), we will also have a large cheese grazing table with dried and fresh fruits and nuts, as well as additional culinary items.I pick wines from my cellar that I have been aging for a while.
How To Cook Roast Beef
Try this easy roast beef recipe which is one of my most popular recipes plus get my tips for how to cook and slice roast beef for juicy, tender roast beef perfection.
Let me first start this recipe post by sharing its original resounding success.
And, when I say “success,” I mean “Dustin loved it.”
And, when I say, “Dustin loved it,” I mean he didn’t stop talking about it for weeks when I first made it. He shared with his friends how delciious it was, he reminisced with me about how tender and juicy it was…He was so thrilled to have a tasty homemade roast beef recipe that tasted so good.
And it’s been like 4 years now, folks, and he still raves about it. Seriously.
I don’t mind – I love it when he thinks my recipes are a hit.
I’d always thought it would be difficult to make roast beef so I had never tried, but now that I know how to cook roast beef, I do it all the time.
It’s shockingly simple and ready in less time than I expect every time I make it. Let me show you how easy it is to make perfect roast beef every time.
How To Cook Roast Beef
Once you learn how to cook roast beef, you’ll be able to replace all that deli meat you’ve been buying at the store and your life will be so much more flavorful and delciious. Promise.
There are a few main steps to cooking roast beef that will help you make your roast beef amazing and tender, which consist mainly in how to choose your beef, how to season it, what temperature to cook it at, at then how to slice it.
We’ll cover how to master all of this in this post. I got you – we’re gonna make some tasty roast beef together.
Best Cuts Of Beef For Roast Beef
Not all beef is created equal for roasting. Some beef, like steaks, are best pan-roasted or grilled, and other beefs, like ground beef are better cooked on the stove top. For the best types of roasts for roasting, look for one of the following:
- Top Round Roast (AKA Inside Round) – this cut of beef is similar to the top sirloin in fat and flavor and is the most common cut used for roast beef.
- Top Sirloin Roast (AKA Top Butt) – this cut is lean and full of flavor with a little but of marbling.
- Bottom Round Roast (AKA Rolled Rump Roast) – this cut is a good budget cut and has more marbling than the Top Round.
- Eye Of Round Roast – this is a circular cut that is very lean so needs to be very thinly sliced when roasted.
Now, it’s always possible to find other cuts of beef that will work for roast beef recipes so don’t be discouraged if you don’t see any of these exact names. You can also ask your butcher what they would recommend as they’ll have the best understanding of what they have available in their meat market for you, too.
How to Make the Tenderest Roast Beef
Okay, so now that we’ve chosen a cut of beef that is expected to be tender, juicy, and flavorful and we’re ready to make it, what’s next?
Well, we need to season it and prep it for the oven. Since this won’t take very long, we need to make sure the oven is ready for the beef so make sure your oven is pre-heated. Placing a roast into an unheated oven will make things tricky because it will throw off your temperatures and timing so I highly recommend you have the oven fully pre-heated and ready to go.
The good news is that seasoning roast beef does not take make energy at all. In fact, it’s an easy prep of inserting a few garlic slices around the roast, lathering it with some olive oil, and then seasoning with sea salt, black pepper, and a few dried herbs for some additional flavor. My favorite herbs to use with roast beef are rosemary and thyme, but you can add mostly anything to it that you’d normally cook with and it’ll taste great.
What Temperature To Cook Roast Beef?
I have found the best temperature to cook roast beef starts at 375 degrees F and then ends a little lower to finish it off at 250 degrees F.
Changing the temperature midway through has the effect of not overcooking the beef and allowing it to gently come up to the right temperature to remove from the oven. I usually remove the roast when it reaches 135 degrees F in the deepest part of the roast because, as it rests for 10 minutes on the counter before slicing, the temperature will continue to rise up to 145 degrees, leaving it perfectly pink and juicy – just the way roast beef is meant to be served.
If you’d prefer your roast beef to be a little less pink, you can remove from the oven a little closer to when it reaches an internal temperature of 140 degrees and allowing it to rest and rise past 145 degrees F. Either way works, it’s simply a matter of preference.
For the most tender roast beef, you’re going to want the final temperature to be right around 145 degrees F. Any higher and the roast will start to become more tough and chewy.
I highly recommend using a digital thermometer to insure your internal meat temperature is where you want it. It removes the guessing out of cooking and helps make the meat the perfect temperature.
How To Slice Roast Beef
Ahh, slicing your roast beef. This is a major step as well to insure the most tender roast beef possible.
When you slice your roast beef, you want to make sure you’re slicing across the grain (as opposed to with the grain).
If you’re not sure how to find the grain, take a look at your roast and look for the long grooves and lines. Those will all tend to go in parallel across the roast in one direction. These are the muscle fibers and we want to cut across them (AKA against them), not with them. If you cut with the grain, you’d be eating an entire long muscle fiber, which would be tough and chewy. Instead, if you cut against the grain, you’re eating just a portion of several of the muscle fibers, which makes for a much more tender bite.
If you need more help on finding the grain, you can watch my video at the end of this post to see exactly how to do it.
It really doesn’t require a lt and these tools and equipment are super versatile in my kitchen.
Okay, so now you know how to choose the best beef for roast beef, how to season roast beef, at what temperature to cook roast beef, and how to slice roast beef for the most tender, juicy, and delciious roast beef you’ve ever imagined. You’re all set to get started making amazing roast beef that will leave you never wanting to buy anything resembling roast beef from a deli again.
Check out this roast beef recipe I have here for you – it’s a simple recipe with no frills – just amazing results every time. It makes super moist, perfectly seasoned, tender roast beef. And it’s so darn easy, too!
Oh, my…you’re in for such goodness!